Editorial "Consolidation without borders" Printed May 18, 2007

    It seemed earlier this year Governor Baldacci’s radical plan to slash the number of school districts in the state would go nowhere. After an initial explosion of interest and a great deal of skepticism, many detractors of the plan began to believe that the plan would come out of the legislature significantly less radical.
    But there are indications that compromises which would make consolidation more or less voluntary and other measures may not come to pass and once again school boards, school administrations and school supporters fear that local control of how children are educated will be sacrificed at the altar of modest savings.
    Perhaps no where else is this fear more palpable than in Cape Elizabeth, where enforced district consolidation will likely mean increased costs and decreased results.
    Blessed with the resources of a largely affluent population, Cape Elizabeth has grown used to being either at the top or among the top handful of school districts that out perform the rest. That this achievement is coupled with relatively per-pupil costs is no accident and people in town should be outraged that the prescription for improving inefficient and mediocre schools will be forced on them. The affluence that helps Cape students to out perform others also provides parents with the option to opt out of public school in Maine all together, either through private schooling or by taking their skills, jobs and wealth out of Maine altogether.
    If the system will be forced to be absorbed into a larger school district, perhaps there is a way to minimize the potential damage. Perhaps Cape Elizabeth could be allowed to explore consolidating with other high performing school systems such as Yarmouth or Falmouth. With modern communication technology is it really necessary for the schools forming a given district to be neighbors? Companies operate in all corners of the world, generals in Oman and Tampa commanded war in Afghanistan– couldn’t a superintendent oversee schools in the same county?
    Of course Cape and Falmouth or Freeport or whomever would be accused of elitism, but that is nothing new and if it meant giving their children the best opportunities to succeed, that would not be anything new either.
–Ward Peck

 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name (required)

 Email (will not be published) (required)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.